Are Financial Advisors Worth It? (2021 Survey)

Overview:  We surveyed over 600 Americans to study their perceptions of monetary recommendation and its value. What we discovered is that relating to monetary recommendation, shoppers aren’t clear on what’s going on, what they’re receiving, and what its worth is.

Are monetary advisors value it? Many shoppers aren’t certain, actually because they aren’t certain what monetary advisors do. Financial recommendation is a fragmented trade, solely midway to being a longtime career. 

Consumers have historically related monetary recommendation with high-end funding advisors and monetary planners that serve prosperous shoppers. Most customers don’t acknowledge that credit score counselors, housing counselors, monetary therapists, and different professionals who work with financially burdened shoppers are additionally monetary advisors.

The definition and function of monetary advisors are altering and evolving. We carried out this survey to grasp if shopper attitudes towards monetary advisors are additionally altering, and what this implies for the way forward for monetary recommendation.

Key Findings

Most shoppers (75%) acknowledge that the potential of monetary recommendation goes past delivering funding returns and into the realm of objectives success. Learn extra

Most respondents (78%) imagine that just some advisors are definitely worth the charges they cost. This implies that pricing strain just isn’t too distant for others! Learn extra

57% of respondents imagine they’ve a monetary advisor (though the time period covers many several types of recommendation). Of the rest, many seem to lack enough belongings to qualify for recommendation underneath the prevailing asset-based charge mannequin. Learn extra

While solely 5% of respondents reported that their expertise of monetary recommendation had been ‘Negative’ (which is encouraging) and practically half (48%) chosen ‘Positive’, a surprisingly massive group (42%) opted for ‘Neutral’ (which is much less encouraging). Learn extra

Only 11% of definitions indicated an explicitly skeptical or jaded perspective to the worth of monetary recommendation. The the rest emphasizes the function of the monetary advisor as a ‘navigator’ in an more and more advanced world. Learn extra

Consumers aren’t clear about what monetary recommendation is, as a result of monetary recommendation is a fragmented trade, solely midway to being a longtime career.


Financial advisors aren’t like different professionals. With a lawyer, accountant, or a health care provider, you may have a way that they’ve been by way of a standard set of hurdles (medical college, the bar examination) and you’ll belief them to take care of sure requirements. 

A lawyer, for instance, could be anticipated to not break shopper privilege, simply because the physician could be trusted to not prescribe inappropriate treatment. If they do both of this stuff, they run the chance of being disbarred or struck from the register, after which they are going to now not maintain skilled standing.

A career is totally different from an trade. In an trade, the intention of the supplier is to promote you as a lot of a given services or products as attainable. A double-glazing salesman doesn’t have a fiduciary responsibility to make sure you get the very best double glazing on the lowest value – that’s your job as a shopper. As the attorneys may put it, the precept of ‘caveat emptor’ (purchaser beware) applies.

Financial recommendation is – presently – someplace in between career and trade. Advisors don’t have the identical skilled standing that a health care provider or surgeon might need, however on the similar time, they take pleasure in extra status than the automobile salesman or property agent.

A giant a part of the issue is that folks don’t have a transparent view of what monetary recommendation is. And that is no surprise, for 3 causes:

  1. The monetary advisor group is very fragmented. Since there isn’t a single path to skilled standing, anybody can declare the function of ‘wealth advisor’, even when they haven’t any {qualifications} in any respect. Consequently, the group accommodates the entire gamut – from precise salesmen pushing monetary merchandise to real specialists who combine information from a number of domains to resolve advanced monetary issues.
  2. There aren’t lots of films or TV reveals about monetary advisors. This might sound like a minor level, till you contemplate what number of authorized and medical dramas have been produced. By distinction, there isn’t a clear view of a monetary advisor within the public consciousness. Financial recommendation is, sadly, not notably dramatic, and so Hollywood tends to give attention to Wall Street capers and company high-jinks, reasonably than tax-loss harvesting for Mr. and Mrs. Jones. 
  3. Financial recommendation has developed significantly in latest a long time. For our grandparents, “financial advice” consisted of a dealer serving to you to purchase and promote particular person shares and bonds. Today, market timing and funding choice is just a part of funding administration, which is itself solely part of the broader area of wealth administration as practiced by its extra superior practitioners at this time. It covers many associated fields, a few of which overlap with legislation (property planning) and accounting (tax technique). It is extra akin to problem-solving than market-trading, and requires a totally totally different skillset

The fragmented and undefined marketplace for monetary recommendation is a giant downside for shoppers and real monetary advisors. The lack of readability round monetary recommendation permits lots of genuinely unhealthy actors to proceed to function underneath its cowl, sometimes on the expense of unwitting shoppers who lose cash on doubtful monetary merchandise, and sincere advisors whose repute suffers from the taint of affiliation.

This could also be altering. One of the advantages of the web age is the transparency it has delivered to many industries that beforehand relied on or traded upon secrecy.

The monetary disaster of 2008 opened many eyes to the borderline (and precise) fraud that’s routinely perpetrated by the establishments who’re charged with our monetary wellbeing. A greater knowledgeable and extra demanding shopper could possibly be simply what the monetary recommendation trade/career must encourage it to lift its sport.

The Results

The survey was carried out in October 2021 and consists of responses from round 620 individuals from throughout the USA. The respondents have been all from households incomes above $100k in annual revenue. We requested the respondents to reply the next questions:

  1. What Is the Point of Having a Financial Advisor?
  2. Are Financial Advisors Worth Their Fees?
  3. Do You Have a Financial Advisor? Do You Need One?
  4. What Has Been Your Experience of Financial Advice?
  5. How Would You Define the Value of a Financial Advisor in One Sentence?

What Is the Point of Having a Financial Advisor?

Not so way back monetary recommendation was restricted to advising traders on what inventory to purchase or when to make a commerce. There are nonetheless advisors who give attention to safety choice and market timing as their essential supply of added worth, however they’re higher termed ‘asset managers’ in that their purpose is just to maximise risk-adjusted returns. 

Even whether it is achievable, merely focusing on increased returns is a slender set of goals and doesn’t take into consideration the purpose of investing, which isn’t ‘to become richer’ however to offer a way of reaching one’s objectives. 

The baseline purpose for most individuals is making certain that they accumulate belongings to stay self-sufficient after retirement. With the rise of the child boomer technology, the monetary recommendation trade has developed a collection of services and products to assist meet this want. For the advisor, retirees are enticing shoppers as a result of they’re sometimes able of considerable wealth, having saved persistently over the course of a lifetime.

However, ‘retirement management’ is just marginally broader than ‘asset management’ as a definition of monetary recommendation, because it restricts recommendation to these aged 55 and over (with enough wealth to speculate). Since everybody has monetary wants, monetary recommendation ought to ideally tackle individuals in any respect life levels, and embody many questions in addition to retirement. 

The in style framework developed by Maslow units out a hierarchy of wants, starting with fulfilling naked requirements (corresponding to meals and shelter) and progressing upwards to wants extra associated to success and self-actualization (e.g. reaching one’s potential) than mere survival.

Maslow’s hierarchy of wants

The developed advisor (often known as a complete monetary planner) helps a shopper on each stage of the Maslow hierarchy and can start the connection by understanding his or her aspirations and objectives referring to profession, household, and legacy.

Home-buying, credit score and debt administration, and faculty financial savings plans are all vital monetary matters that warrant recommendation and are sometimes most pertinent for a shopper of their early or mid-career. A really holistic advisor, due to this fact, serves shoppers of all ages and helps them at each stage.

If we look at the survey outcomes, we see – encouragingly – {that a} majority of shoppers see monetary recommendation as greater than merely ‘getting higher returns’. The largest response group (49%) believes that the worth of recommendation is extra associated to setting and reaching objectives, shifting the worth of the service additional in direction of the upper finish of the Maslow pyramid.

What is the point of having a financial advisor?

Later in Question 5 (“​​How would you define the value of a financial advisor in one sentence?”) those that answered ‘Getting higher than average returns’ on this query tended to outline the worth of monetary recommendation by way of the portfolio, the market, and outperformance. 

Those who answered ‘Helping me set and achieve financial goals’ however, have been extra prone to point out different issues corresponding to plans for his or her kids, tax implications of monetary choices, and assist with their enterprise.

The total conclusion is that persons are conscious that advisors can, or no less than ought to, be broader of their scope of providers than merely delivering extra returns (or as mere ‘conduits’ as one skeptical respondent put it, presumably referring to the apply of pushing monetary merchandise).

As shoppers turn out to be extra assertive on this regard, it’s to be hoped that the inhabitants of monetary advisors will start to resemble this up to date set of expectations.

Are Financial Advisors Worth Their Fees?

Because the worth of a monetary advisor is such a complicated subject, it is just pure that the query of worth in relation to charges is equally fraught.

There’s a rising debate over how advisors ought to cost shoppers for recommendation. In some instances, this is because of regulation (MiFID in Europe, Reg BI within the US). There can also be an ongoing inner debate throughout the recommendation group as to which is the very best charge mannequin (sometimes, it should be stated, carried out by way of what’s finest for the advisor!).

Consumers are notably absent from the talk. To use the phrases of 1 government, monetary recommendation is ‘sold not bought’ – that’s to say, persons are anticipated to not perceive the product or the charge construction, and take no matter they’re given (or regardless of the regulator permits).

This is prone to change sooner or later as a result of heightened transparency of the digital age. People have entry to lower-cost funding choices (e.g. by way of Robo-advisors). While these are unlikely to exchange human monetary advisors as initially feared, it’s nonetheless inserting strain on charges.

Why? Because even when the worth of monetary recommendation has expanded from simply investments to a broader vary of monetary matters, the charge mannequin stays tied to the worth of the portfolio generally, due to the rising dominance of the AUM charge mannequin (charging an annual share charge primarily based on the belongings underneath administration).

Advisors don’t need to transfer away from the AUM charge mannequin as a result of it is vitally worthwhile and has to this point labored properly for them. If shoppers begin to problem the charge stage, this might make the mannequin extremely unprofitable. Owing to mounted prices, a mere 30% discount in charges can translate to a 100% lower in income.

What did the information present?

Are financial advisors worth their fees?

Advisors can take consolation from the truth that over 90% of respondents acknowledged that no less than some advisors are value their charges. This signifies that advisors who can exhibit worth for cash are secure from charge strain in the intervening time.

Viewed from one other perspective although, round 85% of respondents didn’t agree with the assertion that the majority monetary advisors are definitely worth the cash. This might indicate they imagine the true proportion of ‘good’ monetary advisors is fewer than half! 

That’s much less of an endorsement. While skilled advisors could also be shielded, charge strain could be very a lot on the playing cards for the monetary recommendation ‘industry’.

Do You Have a Financial Advisor? Do You Need One?

As we coated within the introduction, as a result of there isn’t a single acknowledged path to skilled standing, people of assorted backgrounds are capable of maintain themselves out as monetary advisors. This makes it exhausting for shoppers to differentiate the extremely certified from these much less so. 

Normally, one would use official designations (e.g CPA, MD)  to find out the standard of an expert. There are so many {qualifications} (and of such various high quality) within the area of monetary recommendation that the result’s a complicated alphabet soup of acronyms, which in all chance solely serves to confuse reasonably than inform potential shoppers.

In the case of the US, the rationale for the confusion is historic. Professor Nathan Harness of Texas A&M has used the metaphor of various ‘tribes’ to elucidate the fragmentation of monetary recommendation. 

are financial advisors worth it - financial planning

He traces every of the modern-day “tribes” again to their origin. One advisor may originate from a background in product distribution, the place the intention is to maximise one’s shut price. Another may come from the world of accounting and CPAs, the place the fiduciary tradition is dominant.

From a shopper’s perspective, nonetheless, it might seem as if each people are performing the identical operate, notably if they’re utilizing the identical language. A monetary plan ready by an insurance coverage salesperson, nonetheless, is extra prone to be a automobile to promote insurance coverage.

The service that’s supplied by a monetary advisor with roots on the planet of accounting is extra prone to be the type of recommendation that the majority respondents to this survey say they need, whereby the advisor optimizes for the shopper’s long-term finest pursuits.

All of this makes the outcomes of the survey query considerably tough to interpret. 

While the majority of respondents (57%) imagine they’ve a monetary advisor, it’s tough to know which tribe the advisor comes from or what kind of recommendation is being delivered. From our perspective, the proportion of these receiving true monetary recommendation (within the complete sense) is prone to be far decrease than 57%. 

What statement would you most agree with?

The indisputable fact that 20% of individuals don’t imagine they want a monetary advisor offers a clearer message. By analyzing how they answered Question 5 (“How would you define the value of financial advice in a single sentence?”), we are able to look at the rationale behind their responses. 

Interestingly, solely a few of these responses have been from true “skeptics” who imagine that monetary recommendation is a waste of time. Rather, this group consisted primarily of respondents who believed they have been capable of deal with issues for themselves (extra about this later). In different phrases, recommendation is a invaluable service for many who want it.

The group that stated they ‘can’t afford a monetary advisor’ can also be vital. 

As advisors have moved to an AUM-based pricing method, it has turn out to be mandatory to limit entry to those that have enough belongings to handle (sometimes 500k or above), in any other case the charges are too low to pay for the service. 

This cut-off level eliminates a big portion of the inhabitants beneath retirement age (who both lack the belongings or shouldn’t have them obtainable handy over to be managed), together with those that may in any other case have been completely satisfied to pay by different means (e.g. % of wage, by the hour).

One of the hallmarks of a real career is that it’s open to all – legislation, medication, and accounting are providers that your complete inhabitants has entry to. Removing this pointless barrier shall be key to unlocking the true potential of monetary recommendation to create rich people reasonably than serve the already rich. 

In the long run, this chart might look very totally different, with the overwhelming majority of respondents sitting in column 3 (“I have a financial advisor”). There may additionally be a standard consensus on what a ‘financial advisor’ is and does.

What Has Been Your Experience of Financial Advice?

Encouragingly for monetary advisors, the variety of ‘negative’ experiences is tiny (round 5%) versus the 47% who stated their experiences had been constructive

However, 42% rated their expertise as impartial, which is a really massive share for a response that’s basically non-committal. After all, what number of vital issues are shoppers usually ‘neutral’ about?

This brings us again to the widespread theme on this report: relating to monetary recommendation, shoppers aren’t clear on what’s going on, what they’re receiving, and what its worth is.

What has been your experience of financial advice?

Digging deeper, we are able to have a look at how every group responded in Question 5 (“How would you define the value of financial advice in a single sentence?”).

Positive respondents, as could be anticipated, gave definitions that targeted on steering, objectives, and value-added providers corresponding to tax recommendation. A big minority targeted on funding returns, implying that there’s nonetheless marketplace for advisors who lead with this as their essential proposition.

Negative respondents tended to query your complete worth of the monetary recommendation providing (e.g. “A waste of time and money!”), and a few feedback (e.g. “Glorified salesperson”)  implied that the respondent had encountered a product-salesperson who had not put the shopper’s curiosity first. While apparently uncommon, these unfavorable experiences clearly engender a hostile perspective to the idea of recommendation normally.

Neutral respondents are essentially the most fascinating class. The skeptical feedback on this class have been extra nuanced than within the ‘Negative’ contingent, with issues primarily centered round uncertainty (“I do not understand how they make money”) and evoking a basic sense of wariness reasonably than absolute disbelief. Many respondents gave clear and concise definitions of what monetary recommendation might and must be. The downside gave the impression to be they’d not skilled it themselves.

As remarked above, the sheer dimension of the impartial class is the primary takeaway – and puzzle – on this query. We would argue that this means confusion greater than the rest, resulting in warning. The hazard is {that a} lack of passionate devotees suggests vulnerability to various options that will current themselves.

How Would You Define the Value of a Financial Advisor in One Sentence?

Given that the majority monetary advisors would battle to reply this (trillion-dollar) query concisely and precisely, we have been impressed with the vary of the responses we obtained! Viewed in composite, it was attainable to derive a reasonably detailed view of the notion of monetary recommendation within the thoughts of the on a regular basis shopper. 

Certain themes emerged, which we’ve got set out beneath.

Investment Management Is Still a Draw for Some (For Now)

A large portion of the individuals (17%) responded to the query purely by way of funding outcomes. For this group, the attraction of an advisor rests on the power to generate increased returns than they might have the ability to do on their very own. In the phrases of 1 respondent, “If they produce, they’re okay.”

As said above, the concept of recommendation as primarily about producing excessive returns is changing into outdated (not least as a result of it’s statistically extremely unlikely that your advisor will have the ability to beat the vast majority of different traders). But for a lot of, the story of the market-beating advisor stays potent.

In this space, respondents appear to worth advisors in 3 ways.

  1. The first is information – advisors are perceived to have real experience in managing cash (to cite one respondent, “Navigates a complicated investment landscape that I myself do not understand”).
  2. Linked to that is the concept that advisors have entry to ‘deals and resources’ not obtainable to the on a regular basis shopper, very like a mortgage dealer or (within the pre-internet days) journey agent.
  3. Also quite common was the concept that shoppers might carry out investing by themselves if solely they’d the time. In the phrases of 1 respondent, “I don’t have the time or the desire to watch the market or understand products and their implications.” The concept is that an advisor is an outsource associate who takes care of a facet of your life in your behalf.

It stays to be seen how sustainable the investment-led proposition shall be, however expertise and more and more self-reliant buyer attitudes might imply that few advisors can proceed to pose as stock-market gurus. For now, as we’ve got stated, this market area of interest seems stable.

A Broader View of Advice

Only 5% of respondents referred to retirement immediately, with most individuals referencing broader goals. While the statements these respondents made have been naturally very high-level, many have been wonderful descriptions of the worth of a complete advisor, and will even be used as advertising taglines by recommendation corporations. For instance:

  • “Professional guidance on difficult decisions”
  • “Helping me navigate my financial life”
  • “Puts my mind at ease about my financial future”
  • “Gives you confidence you are making good decisions with your money.”
  • “Making sense out of mayhem.”

One respondent even raised the purpose that advisors doubtlessly fulfill a niche in our present schooling system. “Since schools do not teach financial literacy, someone has to.” Other widespread concepts used to explain the worth of an advisor embrace:

  • Keeping me on monitor
  • Keeping me from doing one thing silly
  • Making higher monetary choices

Although ‘peace of mind’ is a cliche when speaking about the advantages of monetary recommendation, many respondents referred to the advisor as an individual who “removes the worry” concerning their future. This consists of particularly traumatic life occasions corresponding to bereavement (“Reassuring that someone will help my spouse if I die”.)

Navigating an Increasingly Complex World

There was a particular indication from numerous responses that the necessity for monetary recommendation is definitely rising in at this time’s world, because of the accelerating tempo of change and rising complexity of life. 

This could possibly be as a result of Covid, cryptocurrencies, geopolitical shifts – however the level is that for the common shopper, the world they face just isn’t the one by which they grew up, and a trusted advisor is extra vital than ever. 

This signifies that individuals who didn’t contemplate a monetary advisor mandatory earlier than might now be altering their minds on the topic. This is even successful over former-skeptics, as we see from the remark, “A fiduciary is necessary with our government and financial institutions as unstable as they are now.  As much as I dislike it, they have become necessary now for support.”

Finding the Right Advisor Can Be a Lottery

There is a paradox on the coronary heart of the suggestions. In spite of unfavorable feedback from some (extra on this within the subsequent part), it was noticeable how warmly many different respondents spoke in regards to the good recommendation that they’d obtained previously. 

As already noticed, attitudes to monetary recommendation are – by and huge – extra constructive than unfavorable.

The downside is that this constructive perspective is undermined by the coexistence of excellent and unhealthy actors within the recommendation class, and the issue of distinguishing between them as a possible shopper. 

Two consultant feedback are “An honest advisor is worth their weight in gold,” or “If they’re honest and good at their job, then they’re worth working with.” These statements are endorsements of excellent advisors, however the truth that the author feels the necessity to explicitly name out the phrase ‘honest’ implies that this shouldn’t be the default expectation.

Reasons for Skepticism: More About Advisors Than Advice

Only 11% of definitions indicated an explicitly skeptical or jaded perspective to the worth of monetary recommendation. These 60 responses ranged from outright cynicism (“Most advisers give the same advice to each client.”) to warning (“[The value] depends entirely on the advisor”) and grudging acceptance (“A necessary evil.”)

Believing {that a} service has no worth and mistrusting those that present it are two various things. Even among the many skeptics, those that imagine that recommendation is basically nugatory have been within the minority. The questionable level for many seems to be the integrity of advisors themselves.

As one respondent put it, “He/she should be looking out for me the investor, not ways for them to make more money through me with no regard to my investment return.” Fixing the repute of advisors by instilling a real fiduciary method (versus a gross sales tradition) will go an extended option to successful over the skeptics. 

Dissatisfaction With the Fee Model

Another pressure of frustration got here from a way that monetary advisors are solely serious about those that are already rich, reasonably than serving to individuals turn out to be rich. As one respondent wryly noticed, “[Financial advisors] are for people who don’t need financial advisors.” 

This is linked to the purpose across the charge mannequin. There is one thing perverse about requiring a excessive asset minimal so as to settle for a shopper, like a health care provider with a minimal well being requirement, or a lawyer who solely takes straightforward instances. The indisputable fact that shoppers are sensing this must be a warning signal.

Another telling citation got here from a respondent who just isn’t solely receiving recommendation however is pro-advice, not a skeptic. “Though I might be paying more than I’m getting out of it, if I didn’t have a planner I’d be more worried about retirement.”

This is fascinating as a result of, within the very act of acknowledging the worth and necessity of recommendation, the shopper is behind her thoughts questioning if she is getting overcharged.

This highlights an extra downside with the asset-based charge mannequin: calculating the worth of recommendation as a % of the belongings invested makes far much less sense when the scope of recommendation being given is broader than simply the investments. The charge goes up and down primarily based on the worth of the belongings, reasonably than the service obtained, and therefore shoppers are left questioning if they’re paying the correct quantity.

Closing Words

To sum up, monetary recommendation has a stable basis however has the potential to be a lot greater than it presently is. Chiefly, its mission must be to limit entry to the title of “financial advisor” by revising the necessities and opening up entry to recommendation by restructuring the charge mannequin.

Both shoppers and advisors ought to acknowledge that lots of the individuals who most want monetary recommendation aren’t able to pay a lot for it. That has created industries like credit score counseling, monetary remedy, and a spread of providers designed to offer recommendation to financially burdened – or financially determined – people. Practitioners on this area are additionally monetary advisors. And must be acknowledged as such.

While sure kinds of recommendation could also be displaced sooner or later, the necessity for a monetary navigator has by no means been better, and it’s time that the trade evolves into the career this new world requires.

About This Survey

The survey was carried out in October 2021 and consists of responses from 618 individuals from throughout the USA. The respondents have been all from households incomes above $100k in annual revenue.

Copyright Information:
All the information included on this research is offered through public area. This means all statistics could also be copied with out permission. We do, nonetheless, admire quotation because the supply through a hyperlink.

Matthew Jackson

Download Summary Data (PDF)

The Brief by finmasters

Sign up for The Brief by finmasters, our FREE weekly e-newsletter and get the most recent recommendations on how to make more cash, make investments higher and attain your monetary objectives.

No spam. Ever. We decide to by no means sharing or promoting your private data.